In a mid-May clash that would typically fly under the radar for most Premier League observers, the UEFA Europa League final at San Mamés, Bilbao, has taken on monumental significance for both Tottenham Hotspur and Manchester United, two clubs languishing in the unfamiliar depths of 16th and 17th in the Premier League table. This encounter, far from being a footnote in the season, represents a critical juncture for both teams, each desperate to salvage a campaign marked by inconsistency and disappointment with a piece of silverware that carries not only prestige but also the invaluable prize of UEFA Champions League qualification for the 2025-26 season. For Tottenham, the match offers a chance to end a trophy drought that stretches back to their 2008 EFL Cup triumph under Juande Ramos, a victory that feels like a distant memory for a fanbase starved of success. For Manchester United, it is an opportunity to inject momentum into a faltering rebuild under Ruben Amorim, whose candid assessment of his team as the worst in the club’s storied history has only heightened the stakes. The victors will not only claim the Europa League crown but also secure the financial windfall that comes with Champions League football, offering a lifeline for squad investment and renewal. The losers, however, will be forced to confront the grim reality of a season that ranks among the worst in their modern histories, a failure underscored by their mid-table domestic struggles and the weight of unfulfilled expectations.
For Tottenham, the stakes could not be higher, as they chase their first trophy in over 17 years and their first major European title since Keith Burkinshaw’s side lifted the UEFA Cup in 1983-84. A victory in Bilbao would see Spurs become only the second English club, after Liverpool, to win the UEFA Cup/Europa League three times, a feat that would place them in elite company behind only Sevilla’s seven titles. However, their path to glory is fraught with challenges, not least due to a crippling injury crisis that has robbed manager Ange Postecoglou of key creative forces in midfield. The absence of Dejan Kulusevski, James Maddison, and Lucas Bergvall—players who have collectively contributed 21 assists across all competitions this season—has left Tottenham’s attacking structure stretched thin. Kulusevski and Maddison, with 11 and 10 assists respectively, are pivotal to Spurs’ fluid, attacking style, and their absence places immense pressure on captain Son Heung-min to deliver. Son, who has returned from a foot injury to make his first start since a 2-0 defeat to Aston Villa, remains a beacon of hope for Postecoglou, with 11 goals and 11 assists this season. His recent scoring record against Manchester United—five goals in his last four appearances across all competitions—offers a glimmer of optimism, as does the form of Dominic Solanke, who has emerged as a talisman in this competition. Solanke’s penalty in the quarter-final against Eintracht Frankfurt and his goals in both legs of the semi-final against Bodø/Glimt have underlined his importance, and his knack for finding the net against United makes him a potential match-winner. Yet, Postecoglou’s prickly demeanor throughout the season reflects the pressure he faces, with his future at the club uncertain despite his bold claim in September that he “always wins things in my second year.” A Europa League triumph would not only validate his tenure but also cement his place in Tottenham’s history, making him the first Australian manager to win a major European final.
Manchester United, meanwhile, approach the final under the shadow of their own struggles, with Amorim’s blunt assessment of his squad’s deficiencies setting a sobering tone. The Portuguese manager, who has averaged just 0.92 points per game in the Premier League since taking charge, has been unsparing in his critique, but the Europa League has offered a rare bright spot in an otherwise dismal campaign. United’s thrilling 7-6 aggregate victory over Lyon in the quarter-finals showcased their attacking potential, with their 35 goals in the competition this season trailing only a handful of historic campaigns in UEFA Cup/Europa League history. Their unbeaten record in major European competitions—nine wins and five draws in 14 Europa League matches—stands as a testament to their resilience, even as their domestic form has faltered. Amorim, at 40, has the chance to join an exclusive club of managers who have won major European titles with English clubs at a young age, following in the footsteps of Howard Kendall and Gianluca Vialli. A victory would also make him only the third manager to win a major trophy in his first season at United, after José Mourinho and Erik ten Hag. Yet, Amorim has been pragmatic, cautioning that a trophy will not erase the deeper issues plaguing his squad. The financial boost of Champions League qualification, however, could provide the resources needed to accelerate his rebuild, offering a chance to reshape a team that has been plagued by inconsistency and underperformance.
The historical context of this all-English final adds further intrigue, as it marks the sixth time two English clubs have faced off in a UEFA club competition final, more than any other nation. Tottenham’s involvement in two previous such finals—a 3-2 aggregate win over Wolves in the 1972 UEFA Cup and a 2-0 loss to Liverpool in the 2019 Champions League—gives them a mixed record, while United’s nine major European finals place them second only to Liverpool among English clubs. United’s recent history in such matches is less encouraging, with three losses in their last four finals, including a painful defeat to Villarreal in the 2020-21 Europa League. Their recent record against Tottenham is equally concerning, with Spurs winning all three encounters this season—3-0 and 1-0 in the Premier League, and 4-3 in the EFL Cup. This run marks the first time Tottenham have beaten United three times in a single campaign, and a fourth victory would place them alongside their 1992-93 record against Manchester City as the only instances of Spurs defeating an opponent four times in one season. United’s six-match winless streak against Tottenham, their worst ever against the North London club, adds further pressure, though their 4-3 aggregate win over Spurs in the 1963-64 Cup Winners’ Cup offers a faint historical precedent for optimism.
The tactical battle promises to be an open, end-to-end affair, with both teams thriving on high-pressing, transition-heavy football. Tottenham and United rank among the top sides in the Europa League for shots following high turnovers, with 22 and 23 respectively, while United’s 32 direct attacks are joint-highest in the competition. This style suits players like Bruno Fernandes, whose 46 goal involvements in Europa League history make him the competition’s all-time leader in that metric. Fernandes’ seven goals and four assists this season have been pivotal, and his ability to dictate play could prove decisive. For Tottenham, Solanke and Son will be key, but the likes of Brennan Johnson, with 17 goals this season, could exploit United’s defensive vulnerabilities. The stage is set for a high-stakes, high-octane final, where the outcome will hinge on moments of individual brilliance and the ability to capitalize on the opposition’s frailties. For Tottenham, it is a chance to end decades of heartbreak; for United, it is an opportunity to lay the foundation for a brighter future. Regardless of the result, the San Mamés will bear witness to a clash that transcends the ordinary, with the weight of history and the promise of redemption hanging in the balance.